How do you feel about the way that the Indians are treated by the English?
Could you relate this treatment to another race of the 22nd century?
Do you disagree with my claim or agree, and why or why not?
Thursday, January 7, 2010
Week 2 A Passage To India
As I continued to read A Passage To India, I noticed that I constantly came across stereotypes about the Indians from the Englishmen who lived in India. "Let me explain. Natives don't respect any the more after meeting one, you see....Why, the kindest thing once can do to a native is to let him die,..." The English, according to this quote, believed the Indians to be disrespectful and worthless. They felt that it was there job to come to India and bring about some kind of order within the Natives. To the English, the Indians were their subordinates, even though it was their native land. I however disagree with this notion of the Indians being disrespectful and worthless. All throughout the novel, the English came off more so as the disrespectful ones. They didn't treat the Indians with any respect, and Ronny, a high government official in India from England, even stated that, "We're not out here for the purpose of behaving pleasantly!" Instead they were forcing the Indians or at least trying to force them to adopt their English ways and rules for maintaining what they believed to be justice. The Indians were simply misunderstood because they were not accustomed to the customs of the English. As Aziz stated, they weren't used to wearing such clothing the English wore. Aside from this, the Indians were treated lower than the English. This however is contradicting of one of the reasons why they were in India, which was to convert the Indians to their religious beliefs in God. If they believed that God created everyone equally, then why did they treat the Indians as subordinates? I also found it as an excuse to blame the women for the actions of the men. As Ronny said, they were just trying to appease their women. If this was the case, then they could have stayed in England instead of journeying to India. Ultimately the actions of the English as far as they way the treated the Indians, contradicted their beliefs of how the Indians treated them.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!
To answer your second question, I think this relates to the treatment that americans did to those creatures in the movie Avatar. Now as far as the 21st Century, I think that only stereotypes remain but, mistreatment amongst different races is no longer at this extreme level.
Post a Comment